Today's Labour Shortage? Cue the Robots – TheTyee.ca

Thanks for stopping by The Tyee today. Anytime you’re in the mood to read important stories, written well, we’ll be here. We have a whole team of journalists whose full-time gig is digging up vital and intriguing stories to add to the public conversation.
I founded The Tyee back in 2003 because I saw a real need for a fresh new site that focused on publishing in-depth original reporting about our region. ‘No junk, just good journalism’ has always been our motto.
19 years after starting The Tyee, I couldn’t have dreamed where we are today. In the past few years, we’ve grown our team to a staff of 20. We’ve taken home plenty of awards. Our journalism is read far and wide, and we offer it all completely for free.
The only reason we’ve lasted so long, have grown while other newsrooms have shrunk, and have resisted putting up a paywall is because we have the support of thousands of generous readers who we call Tyee Builders. These wonderful folks pitch in an amount that works for them on a one-time or monthly basis so that we can pay our talented writers and even grow to do more.
We want to be around for the long haul and to meet the demand for quality, fact-based reporting in our public conversation. If you’d like to help us do that, please consider joining Tyee Builders.
You pick the amount, and you can cancel any time.
— David Beers, Founding editor
Thanks for stopping by The Tyee today. Anytime you’re in the mood to read important stories, written well, we’ll be here. We have a whole team of journalists whose full-time gig is digging up vital and intriguing stories to add to the public conversation.
I founded The Tyee back in 2003 because I saw a real need for a fresh new site that focused on publishing in-depth original reporting about our region. ‘No junk, just good journalism’ has always been our motto.
19 years after starting The Tyee, I couldn’t have dreamed where we are today. In the past few years, we’ve grown our team to a staff of 20. We’ve taken home plenty of awards. Our journalism is read far and wide, and we offer it all completely for free.
The only reason we’ve lasted so long, have grown while other newsrooms have shrunk, and have resisted putting up a paywall is because we have the support of thousands of generous readers who we call Tyee Builders. These wonderful folks pitch in an amount that works for them on a one-time or monthly basis so that we can pay our talented writers and even grow to do more.
We want to be around for the long haul and to meet the demand for quality, fact-based reporting in our public conversation. If you’d like to help us do that, please consider joining Tyee Builders.
You pick the amount, and you can cancel any time.
— David Beers, Founding editor
Professor Geraint Harvey is the DANCAP private equity chair of human organization, based in the DAN department of management and organizational studies, Western University. This article originally ran in The Conversation.
Last month, unemployment in Canada reached a record low of 5.2 per cent. Alongside low unemployment, many industries saw — and are still seeing — a worker shortage, with the number of job vacancies in Canada reaching 900,000 in January.
Curious about what our journalism accomplished and how we’re progressing? Dive in.
Both of these things are good for workers, right?
Prospective employers, desperate for new recruits, are “throwing cash at applicants.” Many lower wage jobs have even seen an increase in pay, like the 20-per-cent wage increase for truckers recently announced by Walmart.
The pandemic is partially responsible for this labour shortage, as the immigrant workforce supply dried up throughout the lockdown. However, the aging population in Canada has also been a factor.
Is automation the answer?
The solution to the worker shortage proposed by the Business Development Bank of Canada’s chief economist is increased automation.
Advocates and critics have long argued over the impact of automation on employment. Advocates believe automation can be used to perform mundane or physically demanding jobs, freeing up workers to learn new skills and take on better jobs.
Recent research from the University of Pennsylvania supports the argument that automation creates jobs. The study found that investing in robots boosted the efficiency and quality of work while reducing costs, increasing productivity and creating more job opportunities. Similarly, a 2020 report from Statistics Canada also found that companies that used robots hired more human workers.
The impact of automation on work can only be assessed over the longer term and according to whether vacancies are created by those leaving their jobs or retiring and whether the activities of those departing are fully automated.
But critics have argued that automation and advancements in technology create an hourglass economy where opportunities only exist for highly- and lowly-skilled workers, leaving less work for semi-skilled workers who must either increase their skills or take lower-skilled (and waged) work.
A common example used to illustrate the detriment of technology to employment is the case of Blockbuster. Once a titan of physical video rental with 60,000 employees, Blockbuster was unable to compete with Netflix’s (who only had around 2,500 employees) new streaming services and filed for bankruptcy in 2010. Netflix automated the video rental business while Blockbuster retained its physical labour-intensive model until it was too late.
Automating away tomorrow’s jobs?
The reason why automation hasn’t had a more detrimental impact for workers can be explained by two factors. Firstly, employees are also consumers. To reduce employment is to reduce the market for products, which is bad for manufacturers and capitalism itself.
As a management professor, I often use an incident that supposedly occurred between Henry Ford II and Walter Reuther, leader of the United Automobile Workers trade union, to illustrate this point.
While showing Reuther the new automated assembly lines at his car factory, Ford subtly threatened the future of the union: “How are you going to get those robots to pay your union dues?” Unfazed, Reuther replied: “How are you going to get them to buy your cars?”
Secondly, firms can easily resolve issues with new technology by employing human workers to take over. Take for example, the failure of automation in the fast-food industry and the tale of Flippy, the burger flipping robot, that lasted a single day, only to be replaced by human workers when it couldn’t keep up with demand. Such instances reveal the way in which workers offer an easy substitute for automation that fails to cut the mustard (or flip the burger).
The current situation is different because employers are struggling to source workers. The reliance on automation is becoming a necessity, rather than a source of competitive advantage. Moreover, the labour shortage means that turning to workers as a substitute for failing technology is a less viable strategy, so firms are more likely to persevere in introducing new technology.
It has been argued that about half of the activities undertaken by workers could be automated by 2055.
This does not mean that all of these activities will be automated.
Nor does it mean that 50 per cent of jobs will necessarily disappear in the next 30 years without other jobs emerging as a result.
However, current circumstances, especially the shortage of workers, is a powerful motivation for automation. We could see a significant increase in automation use in the workplace over the next few years.
The challenges of filling worker vacancies may be good news for workers now, but the longer terms consequences still remain to be seen.
Read more: Labour + Industry, Science + Tech
When subscribing to a newsletter edition you’ll also get early notice on Tyee events, news, promotions, partner messages and special initiatives.
Further to the provision of the Personal Information Protection Act, personal information is kept confidential by TheTyee.ca and will not be sold, traded, released, shared or distributed to any other individuals, organizations or agencies without prior consent or notification.
Measures have been enacted to ensure the integrity of personal information and to protect it from misuse, loss or alteration. All information submitted to The Tyee is only available to employees or sub-contractors who are bound by agreement with The Tyee to keep the information private. E-mail addresses are only used for the purposes of Tyee-related correspondence or comment moderation.
If you have concerns related to your privacy please contact us at info@thetyee.ca
Comments that violate guidelines risk being deleted, and violations may result in a temporary or permanent user ban. Maintain the spirit of good conversation to stay in the discussion.
*Please note The Tyee is not a forum for spreading misinformation about COVID-19, denying its existence or minimizing its risk to public health.
Do:

• Be thoughtful about how your words may affect the communities you are addressing. Language matters
• Challenge arguments, not commenters
• Flag trolls and guideline violations
• Treat all with respect and curiosity, learn from differences of opinion
• Verify facts, debunk rumours, point out logical fallacies
• Add context and background
• Note typos and reporting blind spots
• Stay on topic

Do not:

• Use sexist, classist, racist, homophobic or transphobic language
• Ridicule, misgender, bully, threaten, name call, troll or wish harm on others
• Personally attack authors or contributors
• Spread misinformation or perpetuate conspiracies
• Libel, defame or publish falsehoods
• Attempt to guess other commenters’ real-life identities
• Post links without providing context

Employers are responding to worker scarcity by ramping up automation. What’s the long-term impact?
BC’s home-share program demands a lot and pays little, say some providers.
BC’s disasters show high-speed internet is an essential service. How to fix colonial policies depriving rural reserves.
Vancouver’s fire department says it responded to over 300 fires at SROs last year.
Verses of love and loss for our endangered flora, fauna and ecosystems, compiled by Vancouver’s poet laureate.
Efforts in Alberta stumbled. Why did organizers in Staten Island prevail?
Between 1973 and 1994, Canada built 16,000 affordable homes a year. Why can’t we do that now? Our latest Hot, Hot Housing column.
Sámi artists celebrate their cultural identities in the 15th annual Coastal Dance Festival.
Six ways to help young people cope, including a definition of hope that fits our times.
Victoria’s medical cannabis club faces $6.5 million in fines and closure.
Also, (fake) doctor, what’s your take on tanned testicles? (A friend wants to know.)
Ever wondered how Tyee reporters get around when we write our stories?

What Do You Think Canada Should Be Doing to Support Ukraine?
Take this week’s poll

source